The 4th post in a series in which we have been learning about Interactive Whiteboards for the classroom.
Three weeks ago I started this effort with a post in which I researched market leaders and confirmedÂ that the ubiquitousÂ SMART Board is the clear market leader (with about 50%Â market share). Of the many other manufacturers that split the rest of this large and growing market, Promethean is a name I've come across frequently. This week I experienced a demonstration ofÂ their ActivBoard andÂ variousÂ related products that Promothean offers for the classroom.
Sales Consultant Christina Godlewski from PrometheanÂ Partner Logical Choice Technologies visitedÂ our college this past Thursday with a full sized mobile ActivBoard in tow (I believe it was the ActiveBoard 300). After an overview of many of the instructional products offered by Promethean, the ActivBoard was demonstrated, with a focus on the ActivInspire software that comes with it.
The ActivBoard appears to be prettyÂ similarÂ to today's “gold standard”Â SMART Board, but there were a number ofÂ features and servicesÂ through whichÂ Promothean seeks to differentiate their offeringsÂ from theÂ competition, including the following:
- Durability: The ActiveBoard has a highly durable surface, unlike the SMART Board's touchboard surfaceÂ (the ActivBoard does not operate by touch).
- Promethean Planet: The Promethean PlanetÂ social network has every appearance of a valuableÂ community resource for educators who utilize the Promethean products for the classroom.Â In aÂ comment here a couple weeks ago,Â reader Dallas McPherson stated, “Iâ€™ve used both Smart and Promethean brand whiteboards and prefer the support of PrometheanPlanet.com with over 14,000 lesson plans that are already broken down by grade, subject, and standards. When it comes to integration of tech in the classroom, there is no substitute for that kind of support.”Â
- Unique two-pen mode: The ActiveBoard featuresÂ a unique two-pen mode, in which one user can play the role of the teacher or facilitator, and the other user can play a participative role.
- The ActiveXpression student response device. This LRS (Learning Response System) tool is considered state of the art, and can be used with other interactive whiteboards.
- Thousands of available Lesson Plans for the ActivInspire software:Â These lesson plans have been developedÂ by other teachers, and are available on the Promethean Planet site.
- TheirÂ software: Promethean considers the the ActivInspire software a differentiator, and it is certainlyÂ a highly functionalÂ whiteboard application,Â but it was notÂ immediately obviousÂ to me if anythingÂ about this software actually sets it apart from other whiteboard apps like Smart Technology's Notebook software. One thing I was excited to learn is that the ActiveInspire application is available in a personal version for free download.Â I am going to check out this week – this could be a great app to use, independant of the specific whiteboard ultimately chosen.
This video is one of a series of “Teacher Features” posted byÂ user PrometheanUSWebÂ on YouTube. These features focus onÂ individual teachers who have made great use of the ActiveBoard products in the classroom, and provide additional insight into these systems:
Promethean positions itself as a provider ofÂ solutions for the whole classroom, andÂ has a wider range of supportive and related products than many other whiteboard providers. Based on my exposure to interactive whiteboards so far, the ActivBoard seems to be every bit as good as the popular SMART Board, but without a touch capability (which isn't necessarily a bad thing).
So far in this series we've learned about SMART Boards online, reviewedÂ a demonstration of theÂ PolyVision Ä“no offering, and examinedÂ Promethean's offerings. Our next steps will include:Â trying out thisÂ inexpensive “Wii Board” technique,Â andÂ collaborating with our faculty basedÂ work group to determine how we will move forward with the decision making process. I look forward discussing our progress, and wrapping this series up by selectingÂ the product(s)Â we willÂ be using for a small scale trial rollout.
A smart interactive whiteboard can make learning more fun in the classroom. It allows teachers to write on the screen and project it into the classroom, enabling them to present lessons on a larger scale. Students can interact with the lesson, allowing them to apply what they\’ve learned in real-time. Teachers can create an interactive quiz on the screen, too. If they don\’t have a smart board, students can still answer questions by using a computer or construction paper placed over a light sensor. You also visit our website
[…] screencast was definitely a challenge but I persevered. Just this week I went to a training on our Promethean Board with ActivInspire software in order to create more engaging lessons for our RSP students at […]
We have had Promethean ActivBoards for two years now after going through a selection process that compared and contrasted the options. We’re very pleased. Answer to the dual pen question: Yes, in dual user mode both pens can be use anywhere on the board simultaneously. And I have heard that the soon to be released boards and software will accept up to four inputs! Get those students up to the board and interacting with the content!!
[…] SMART Boards in the Classroom PolyVision Ä“no whiteboards: A great alternative to the SMART Board Prometheanâ€™s Interactive Whiteboard and related instructional products […]
[…] suggests that SMART Technologies has the upper hand, but in fact, it only has about 50% market share globally. While that’s nothing to sneeze at, there are plenty of competitors. Promethean in particular […]
Social comments and analytics for this post…
This post was mentioned on Twitter by EmergingEdTech: Promethean ActiveBoard demo review on EmergingEdTech: http://bit.ly/69Qtpu…
[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Kelly Walsh, Dallas McPheeters. Dallas McPheeters said: thx 4 the mention, K. Walsh http://bit.ly/69Qtpu even w/ my name misspelled. Promethean IWB is easy 2 ramp up 2 4 Teacher adoption. 🙂 […]
Great review! I appreciate you breaking it down by bullet points.
In regards to the comment above, I’ve used both types of technology and found that I like having the pen because you can hover and you can right click. More and more websites and applications require hovering to use all features.
It is true that many LRS systems will work on other boards, but then you have to run 2 pieces of software and they cannot talk to one another. It is much easier to just get the same brand if you can do so from the beginning.
In regards to dual pen usage, a good question to ask is if both pens can be used anywhere on the board or just in certain areas. Also, does the system recognize each pen independently and react as such or just as “two pens?”
Those are all good questions to ask though IWB user.
Good post – it is interesting to see peoples impressions from demos/sales pitches. Could you follow up with further detail on why you think not having touch ‘is not necessarily a bad thing.’ In my opinion, it is very important – if not, lots of tech wouldn’t be moving towards touch, multi-touch, etc. Apple, Microsoft, HP, etc etc all moving towards touch as the primary way to interact with content. Pens for writing, touch for manipulating. With things like Windows 7 and other OS’s going to gestures/multi-point/multi-touch I wonder what that experience would be like – do you use multiple pens? What did the Promethean person say? What about Polyvision (the other one you reviewed)?
Re: LRS/SRS/(other names) – all the clickers work with any IWB. eInstruction works with any, Quizdom works with any, SMART’s work with any, etc – they are all software driven, so they all can work with any board, right?
Re: Two -pen mode – have you seen the eInstruction Dual-Board? That has used 2 pens for quite some time. SMART has a dual-user board coming out in the next few weeks too. Not sure if others do multi-user.
Re: Promethean Planet – lots of stuff there. Have you checked out the SMART Exchange? I also seem to find many more community-based sites out there for SMART – something that takes it beyond just the manufacturer created/supplied community to the grassroots level. There is also a new eInstruction community site that they are slowly building, as well as other sites from other companies as well..