A growing number ofÂ schools have launched programs toÂ provide iPads to students. WhatÂ returns is this investment yielding?
There's no doubt the iPad is a hot topic in education technology today. Just about every week, my preconfigured Google Alerts deliverÂ stories about schools that have decided to provide iPads to their students. With this trend on the rise, the question arises as toÂ how well this investment is paying off at schools that haveÂ taken the plunge.
This week I decided to do a little web research toÂ learn more about this topic. Searching for phrases like â€œipads in our schools what worked what didn'tâ€Â immediately returnedÂ a number of relevant articles. Naturally, I'm sharing my findings here, and hope to encourage a dialogue with readers to learn about theirÂ experiences and insights.
Naselle High School – teachers and students motivated and engaged
The first article I came across was this one, about the rollout of iPads at Naselle High School in Washington state in the US. Here are a fewÂ highlights fromÂ the article that stood out for me:
- They put some solid effort intoÂ intoÂ implementation planning. They did things like loading the iPads with many education-specific apps that did not require Internet access, and offering a $50 per year insurance policy to parents to helpÂ cover any possible damage to the iPad.
- These statements from students:Â â€œBeing able to be paperless, not having a lot of loose files in my binder, and best of all, the feeling of having something awesome.â€; â€œThe iPads make it easy to look up words and cut down on all the stuff you have to take home for math. You don't have to take home your paper, calculator and math book. Now, we just take home our math book and iPad.â€
- FromÂ the section discussing teacher motivation and engagement:Â A ninth-grade teacher has integrated the iPads into PE class, withÂ an application that, â€œallows the kids to measure heart and breathing rates while they reference the national PE fitness standards onlineâ€;Â the director of special education is thrilled with the iPad as she discovers, â€œhow well children with learning disabilities respond to the portable computersâ€; a science teacher is, “leveraging the enormous potential of the iPads to engage student interest and extend learning beyond the classroom.”
Lincoln Elementary School – information at student's fingertips
The next story I found explained how a pilot project with 60 iPads for students at Lincoln Elementary School in Little Falls, Minnesota, quickly evolved intoÂ hundreds of units, distributed throughout district schools. Again, some of the content of the article jumped out at me, particularly these reflections from a teacher and a couple students:
- â€œFifth-grade teacher Shawn Alholm said the students have been learning so much by having the iPads, including how the technology works and learning more information about various topics. Alholm said if a student doesn't know a word or how to pronounce it they can easily look it up. If they want to learn more about a historical person, it's all at their fingertips. Alholm said there also are educational websites on the iPads that also help students with their mathematics.â€
- â€œFifth-graders Ethan Wickstrom and Logan Linhardt both said that using the iPads has been fun and they've learned a lot more than they would have without them. The students also said that it wasn't hard for them to figure out how to use them. With a chuckle, Ethan said that carrying the iPad around is much easier than carrying a lot of textbooks around. It helps you focus more on your homework, said Logan. You don't rush through it as fast.â€
Higher Education – a more balancedÂ perspective?
The two stories above sound great, and offer a very positive perspective on iPads in education, but what about the downsides – the issues, the distractions they can provide, lessons learned? As an experienced IT manager, I know that all technologies come with trade offs.
When I added â€œhigher educationâ€ to my search criteria, one of the first articles I came across was,Â â€œiPads Could Hinder Teaching, Professors Sayâ€, from The Chronicle of Higher Education. The March 2011 article states, “Despite the iPad's popularityâ€”Apple has sold nearly 15 million of them and just came out with the iPad2 … early studies indicate that these finger-based tablets are passive devices that have limited use in higher education. They are great for viewing media and allow students to share readings. But professors cannot use them to mark up material on the fly and show changes to students in response to their questions, a type of interactivity that has been a major thrust in pedagogy.” (I'm not so sure that there aren't apps that can provideÂ some of that functionality – KW).
The article contains a lengthy and informative section discussing “Pluses and Minuses”. Even more illuminating is the comments section, where dozens of readers spar verbally and take sides – there can be no doubt that this is a hot button topic, with many defenders and detractors. Comments range from suggestions of banning the use of electronic devices in the classroom entirely, to claims that the author had made up his mind (against the iPad) before writing the article.
One thread of discussion that rang true for me is that these devices are not replacements for desktop or laptop computers – they are a whole new category of device, with a different set of functionalities,Â and should be considered in that light.
I thoroughly enjoyed reading these articles and intend to find and share more of them.Â How much of the positive feedback in some of these articles is ‘new toy' hype, and how much is based on relevant factors like the undeniable ease of portability and use of the iPad? What are we going to be saying about them a year or two down the road, after many of these rollouts have settled in and results become clearer?
I'm going to continue with this topic next week. In the meanwhile, if any of you have experiences you want to share, please comment. We want to hear the downsides too – what have the challenges been? What should institutions that are considering iPads avoid – are there clear pitfalls? Are there specific practices that can help ensure success? Also, if you've come across other good articles on the topic, feel free to share them here as well. Thanks!
Related Posts (if the above topic is of interest, you might want to check these out):
10 Excellent iPad Applications for Teachers
Letâ€™s stop misspending education technology dollars
Emerging Education Technologies: Approaches To Staying Informed